In our fast-paced world, the toaster is one of the favorite kitchen appliances to help make ready-to-eat breakfast: toast, English muffins, bagels, waffles. However, there isn’t a one-size-fits-all toast; there are actually a huge variety of options and upgrades to choose from: metal or plastic, 2- or 4-slice toaster, and short or long toast.
Thus, it’s understandable if you feel overwhelmed when pinning down the right model for you. Fortunately, we’ve scoured the web and expertly handpicked the top 9 best toasters designed to do more than just toast plain slices of bread.
- 1 Best Toaster America’s Test Kitchen
- 1.1 1. Cuisinart CPT-142P1 4-Slice Compact Plastic Toaster
- 1.2 2. KRUPS KH734D Breakfast Set 4-Slot Toaster
- 1.3 3. Hamilton Beach Keep Warm 2 Slice Toaster
- 1.4 4. IKICH Toaster 2 Long Slot, Toaster 4 Slice Stainless Steel
- 1.5 5. Cuisinart Touch to Toast Leverless Toaster
- 1.6 6. Breville BTA830XL Die-Cast Smart Toaster 4-Slice Long Slot Toaster
- 1.7 7. Breville BTA840XL Die-Cast 4-Slice Smart Toaster
- 1.8 8. Smeg TSF01RDUS 50’s Retro Style Aesthetic 2 Slice Toaster
- 1.9 9. Revolution Cooking R180 High-Speed 2-Slice Stainless Steel Smart Toaster
- 2 How to Choose the Best Toaster
- 3 Conclusion
Best Toaster America’s Test Kitchen
1. Cuisinart CPT-142P1 4-Slice Compact Plastic Toaster
Our top pick is a Cuisinart CPT-142P1 4-Slice Compact Plastic Toaster with a perfect blend of modern and classic style. This model is a treat to eyes from any angle and delivers excellent performance with incredible performance.
This humble kitchen gadget comes with several toasting functions: Reheat, Cancel, Defrost, Bagel, and Toast. The Cuisinart CPT-142P1 4-Slice Compact Plastic Toaster is equipped with a high lift lever to pop the toast out for easy and safe removal.
Further, this model rocks 1.5-inch toaster slots that are wide enough to toast your sliced bread, bagels, frozen pancakes, toaster pastries, and thin and thick french toast. More so, it has a wide range of shade control settings for a perfect browning result.
Even better, it offers two separate control panels allowing users to toast two sets of toast with different settings. More importantly, it comes with a removable crumb tray for easy cleanup. Plus, users can wrap the cord underneath the unit for a clumsy-free experience.
- Extra-wide slots
- Dual Independent Toasting Controls
- High lever lift for easy toast removal
- Wide range of shade settings
- The adjustment dial could be better.
2. KRUPS KH734D Breakfast Set 4-Slot Toaster
The KRUPS KH734D Breakfast Set 4-Slot Toaster is a 4-slice toaster designed to toast up to four bread slices to crispy perfection. Thanks to its dual independent control panel, users can toast two sets of toast at specific browning levels at the same time.
What’s more? It rocks an extra-large, self-centering slot to accommodate an array of bread, including English muffins, buns, bagels, and many more. The KRUPS KH734D Breakfast Set 4-Slot Toaster comes with six browning settings to allow users to achieve the perfect browning level.
In addition, this kitchen gadget features four push-button functions: Defrost to toast frozen bread with consistent results, Reheat for warming your cold toast without altering the brownness, Bagel to toast the inside and warm the outside of the toasts and Cancel to stop all toasting functions instantly.
It is also equipped with a high lift lever to pop up smaller pieces of bread for easy and safe retrieval. Similarly, it features a user-friendly modern design and includes a removable crumb tray for an easy cleaning experience.
- Two-year worldwide warranty
- Handy cord storage
- User-friendly modern design
- Reliable crumb tray
- Not very consistent
3. Hamilton Beach Keep Warm 2 Slice Toaster
The Hamilton Beach Keep Warm 2 Slice Toaster is an accommodating appliance designed to allow you to fit your foods without having to cram or smash them. This model comes with extra-wide slots, making it suitable for toasting bagels and thick-sliced slices of bread.
This model features an optional keep warm setting and notify users when the toast is finished but keep the toast warm for up to 3 minutes without over-toasting. This appliance comes with special buttons for Defrost and Bagels.
Here’s more: this unit features a cool-wall, stainless steel exterior to ensure this appliance stays cool on the outsides and easy food retrieval. Hamilton Beach Keep Warm 2 Slice Toaster sport a special design to deliver the extra boost needed to lift your food higher for hassle-free removal.
- Attractive stainless steel appearance
- Clutter-free storage
- 3-minute auto-shutoff
- Cool-wall, stainless steel sides
- Toast slightly unevenly
4. IKICH Toaster 2 Long Slot, Toaster 4 Slice Stainless Steel
This is another decent choice for people looking to purchase one of the best 4-slice toasters. This model is ideal for toasting four slices of Pullman load, muffins, sandwich bread, etc., or two pieces of larger and longer bread like sourdough bread, artisan bread.
IKICH Toaster 2 Long Slot, Toaster 4 Slice Stainless Steel offer more flavor choice, thanks to its 6-install toasting gears for different browning levels. This unit is big and compact enough to squeeze into any countertop space without looking odd.
This model comes with three smart functions included Defrost, Reheat, and Cancel, to cater to your daily toast needs. Also, it has a warming rack that pops up easily as you push down the lift lever at the back for reheating heat croissants, heat rolls, and pastry hassle-free.
- Three smart functions
- Easy to clean
- Six browning control for perfect toast
- Built-in warming rack
- Pops up toast with too much force
5. Cuisinart Touch to Toast Leverless Toaster
This model features a seamless blend of state-of-the-art design and digital technology, making the Cuisinart Touch to Toast Leverless Toaster a versatile and intuitive kitchen gadget. This model helps complement your kitchen decor while delivering outstanding performance with powerful features like a countdown timer, leverless lift, and digital interface.
It comes with a digital shade control for a huge variety of browning options and a countdown timer to notify uses when the toast is ready. Even better, this model features a removable crumb tray that makes it easy to clean.
- Multiple toasting function
- Features countdown timer and digital toast shade settings
- Easy to clean
- Sleek design
- Durability issues
6. Breville BTA830XL Die-Cast Smart Toaster 4-Slice Long Slot Toaster
This model features a modern, sleek design and die-cast steel construction to deliver excellent and reliable performance. With its elegant one-touch automation, Breville BTA830XL Die-Cast Smart Toaster 4-Slice Long Slot Toaster is ahead of the game.
What’s more? This unit comes with ‘Lift and Look’ functionality to check out your toast and decide if it needs to toast a little more using the ‘A Bit More’ function. Besides, this kitchen gadget features dual independent toast control to provide you with different levels of brownness.
- Equipped with lots of function
- Has a Toasting Progress LED Indicator
- Intelligent one-touch auto lowering
- Dual independent toast controls
- Uneven toasting after a year
7. Breville BTA840XL Die-Cast 4-Slice Smart Toaster
The Breville BTA840XL Die-Cast 4-Slice Smart Toaster is engineered to deliver perfect toast every time. This model allows you to toast with two different levels of browning at once. It has extra-wide slots to accommodate your pastry, Bagel, or artisanal bread.
Additionally, it delivers incredible performance with its Dual Independent Toast Controls for customized toast levels. More so, it features a toasting progress LED indicator to monitor your food for the perfect brownness level.
This model comes with five settings, including Bagel, Defrost, Lift & Look, and A Bit More. Breville BTA840XL Die-Cast 4-Slice Smart Toaster comes with four extra-wide slots to accommodate all types of bread.
- Intelligent One-Touch auto lowering
- Features lots of settings
- Push-button controls for a convenient mode of operation
- 1-year limited
- The lowering/lifting mechanism is not very reliable
8. Smeg TSF01RDUS 50’s Retro Style Aesthetic 2 Slice Toaster
The Smeg TSF01RDUS 50’s Retro Style Aesthetic 2 Slice Toaster is another excellent device built to add style to any kitchen. This model features a powdered-coated steel body for a sturdy feel and a polished chrome base for aesthetics.
Other interesting things about this toaster is its backlit chrome knob and stainless steel ball level knob to offer incredible functionality and improve your kitchen style. The Smeg TSF01RDUS 50’s Retro Style Aesthetic 2 Slice Toaster is available in several color options to match your taste.
However, it offers six different browning levels and three preset programs: Bagel, Defrost and Reheat. This appliance rocks anti-slip feet and automatic slice pop up for easy removal.
- Three preset programs
- Automatic slice pop up
- Several color options
- Removable stainless steel crumb tray
- On the pricey side
9. Revolution Cooking R180 High-Speed 2-Slice Stainless Steel Smart Toaster
Revolution Cooking R180 High-Speed 2-Slice Smart Toaster is equipped with a proprietary InstaGlo heating system featuring a wide color touchscreen control to ensure you toast evenly, fast, and consistently.
This model is a solution to burnt toast and slow toast. It’s designed to deliver crispy results on the outsides with the perfect toast shade setting. This toaster allows you to toast two slices of pastries, frozen waffles, English muffins, bagels, and bread.
- Five food settings
- Three preset modes
- Seven browning levels
- Large screen
- Not ideal for Rye bread
How to Choose the Best Toaster
When purchasing a new toaster, you must consider a couple of things to consider before parting with your money.
1. Finish & Design
Determine whether you want an appliance to be the centerpiece on your countertop or you simply want the gadget to blend in. It would also help if you considered whether you want to keep the appliance out on your worktop always or somewhere else in your cabinet.
Thus, compare the appliance’s dimension and your available space in your kitchen before making a choice. The latest models are available in different finishes, ensuring you find the perfect one for your kitchen style.
2. Slot Size
If you intend to make breakfast for the whole family, you should consider purchasing the 4-slot toaster to make many servings fast. However, these models are not compact and will take up space on your worktop. Also, toasters with extra-wide slots can accommodate artisan loaves or thicker bread.
3. Extra Benefits
A toaster featuring the Reheat pr defrost function will help you make breakfast faster and easier since you can warm or defrost it without any hassle.
We’ve reviewed the top 9 best toasters out there. Now, it’s your turn to make a choice, considering the factors discussed in the buying guide section for a smart decision.